### The Number 0.999...

October 14, 2010 The recent content of this blog has been somewhat heavy reading, Nobel Laureates, general relativity, and all that, so it's time for some light diversion. Mathematics has its lighter and more accessible moments, although a perusal of recent papers on arXiv might convince you otherwise. Maurice Allais, an able practitioner of applied mathematics whom I eulogized in yesterday's article, had the following opinion of mathematics:"Any author who uses mathematics should always express in ordinary language the meaning of the assumptions he admits, as well as the significance of the results obtained. The more abstract his theory, the more imperative this obligation. In fact, mathematics are and can only be a tool to explore reality. In this exploration, mathematics do not constitute an end in itself, they are and can only be a means."[1]Now, the promised diversion. So, you really think that the number "0.999..." is smaller than one? "0.999..." appears to be a real number, not a rational number, like 1/3, so how could it possibly be equal to the rational number 1? There's a 28 page paper in the The Montana Mathematics Enthusiast that reviews proofs that "0.999..." is identical to one.[2] I discussed this number in a previous article (A Not So Limiting Case, November 8, 2007), where I presented the following proof:

• Let a = 0.999...Here's another proof.

• then 10a = 9.999...

• subtracting 10a - a = 9.999... - 0.999

• 9a = 9

• a = 1

• 1/9 = 0.111...Another proof, presented by Leonhard Euler in his Elements of Algebra, appears below. Euler's equation is for 9.999..., which resolves to 10, but the idea is the same.

• 9 x (1/9) = 0.999...

• 1 = 0.999...

*Section 468 of Euler's Elements of Algebra (John Farrar, trans, Hilliard, Gray & Co., Boston, 1836).*

The principle behind Euler's proof is that any convergent infinite series of the form

a(r)has the sum (ar)/(1-r), provided that |a| < 1. In our case, using a = 9 and r = (1/10) gives the decimal representation for 0.999..., and the sum 0.9/0.9 = 1. Many students encounter this identity with disbelief. After all, even after writing many nines after the decimal point, the number still seems to fall short of one by a known amount that can be expressed exactly. That's why mathematics is both wonderful and intimidating at the same time.^{1}+ a(r)^{2}+ a(r)^{3}+ a(r)^{4}+ ...

### References:

- Maurice Allais, "La formation scientifique, Une communication du Prix Nobel d'économie," address to the Académie des Sciences Morales et Politiques (1997), as quoted on Wikiquote.
- Karin Usadi Katz and Mikhail G. Katz, "When is .999... less than 1?," The Montana Mathematics Enthusiast, vol. 7, no. 1 (January, 2010), pp. 3-30; available also at http://arxiv.org/pdf/1007.3018.
- 0.999... Page on Wikipedia.

*Permanent Link to this article*

Linked Keywords: Nobel Laureates; general relativity; mathematics; arXiv; Maurice Allais; The Montana Mathematics Enthusiast; Leonhard Euler; convergent infinite series.

RSS Feed

### Google Search

Latest Books by Dev Gualtieri

**Previews Availableat Tikalon Press**

*STEM-themed novel for middle-school students*

*Mathematics-themed novel for middle-school students*

*Complete texts of LGM, Mother Wode, and The Alchemists of Mars*

Other Books

- Fifth Force, October 2, 2023

- The Birthday Problem, September 25, 2023

- Iron as a Fuel, September 18, 2023

- Cosmic Asymmetry, September 11, 2023

- Work, September 4, 2023

- The Monty Hall Problem, August 28, 2023

- Memristors, August 21, 2023

- Aperiodic Tiling, August 14, 2023

- Fondant Physics, August 7, 2023

- The Gravitational Constant, July 31, 2023

- Length of a Day, July 24, 2023

- Random Walks, July 17, 2023

- Gravitational Lensing, July 10, 2023

- Tiny Bubbles, July 3, 2023

- Thales' Measure of the Sun, June 26, 2023

- Tetrataenite Magnets, June 19, 2023

- Utilitarian Music, June 12, 2023

- Medieval Volcanism, June 5, 2023

- Rare Earths from Bacteria, May 29, 2023

- Georges Lemaitre, May 22, 2023

- Reading Old Manuscripts, May 15, 2023

- The IQ Flynn Effect, May 8, 2023

- Cosmic Water, May 1, 2023

- Warm Whales, April 24, 2023

- Jumping Beans, April 17, 2023

- Gordon Moore (1929-2023), April 10, 2023

- Speed of Light, April 3, 2023

- Amorphous Ice, March 27, 2023

- Curly Hair, March 20, 2023

- Optical Communication, March 13, 2023

- Hygroscopic Energy, March 6, 2023

### Deep Archive

Deep Archive 2006-2008

**Blog Article Directory on a Single Page**