A Willing Suspension of Disbelief
September 10, 2014
The key to a good fictional work, whether a book or film, is a willing suspension of disbelief, a phrase coined by English poet, Samuel Taylor Coleridge. Coleridge is known especially for his epic poem, The Rime of the Ancient Mariner. This 1798 work has elements much like a science fiction story of today, with a sailing ship set off course to Antarctica, a place so foreign at the time that it might as well have been the Moon.
There is a genre of science fiction called hard science fiction in which the author strives for scientific accuracy. In such works, there is just a stretching of the imagination, but no breaking. My two novels are hard science fiction, but some fictional works take great liberties with the reader's or viewer's suspension of disbelief. Examples would be most of the many "B movies" found on the Syfy channel.
I was reminded of the lack of accuracy in science fiction films while viewing the 1970 film, Beneath the Planet of the Apes, last weekend on Turner Classic Movies (TCM). My wife and I enjoy TCM, since it shows films, albeit older films, with no commercial interruption. With Zardoz as an exception, I don't enjoy watching apocalyptic and dystopian films. However I had seen this particular film at its theatrical release, and I was interested to see why I enjoyed watching it forty years ago.
Beneath the Planet of the Apes is the sequel to the 1968 film, Planet of the Apes. The first film is based on the 1963 novel, La Planète des Singes, by French author, Pierre Boulle. The plot of the first film is that the surviving astronaut of a crash landing on a planet, supposedly far distant from Earth, finds that the planet is ruled by intelligent, talking apes. The roles of humans and apes are reversed, with mute humans hunted by the apes. At the end of the film, it's found that the planet is actually Earth about 2,000 years in the future after a nuclear war.
The plot of the sequel is that the surviving astronaut of an expedition to trace the fate of the first expedition crash lands on the same planet. He finds that he's landed on the future Earth, near New York City, in the middle of the movie. He discovers the first astronaut, and they team in an attempt to stop a race of telepathic humans from detonating a doomsday nuclear device that they worship.
I'm as willing as most to suspend some beliefs while watching science fiction films. As a Star Trek fan, I need to believe in faster-than-light travel, transporters, and the idea that the Klingons didn't destroy themselves long ago. The Ape movies, however, had serious problems that are hard to dismiss, as I'll recount.
First is the idea that the astronauts don't immediately know that they're on Earth, and not on an earthlike exoplanet far distant from Earth. Anyone trained as an astronaut should be familiar with even a few constellations, so a single night's passage would have raised the possibility. Even someone not familiar with the constellations should recognize the appearance of the Moon.
Second, everyone speaks English. Since this facilitates the plot of these movies to such a great extent, I don't really object. A second-order problem is that the English language did not change in 2,000 years. Just read the 700 year old Canterbury Tales to see how much the English language has changed in a shorter time. Even if the apes had been taught perfect English 2,000 years prior, it would have been easier for them to vocalize certain sounds than others, so there would be a rapid evolution of the language.
Although the spacecraft in the films were bound by light speed, there was still the misconception that radio communications with Earth would be instantaneous. Also, everyone arrives at the same place. Earth is a big place, but the two ships, the ape city, and the telepathic humans are quite close to each other. How many 50 mile x 50 mile patches of land exist on the Earth? The land area of the Earth is about 57 million square miles, so (57,000,000/2,500) = 22,800.
I'm actually somewhat open-minded about telepathy. Not that it exists, today, but that it might evolve. The human brain is rife with electrical activity, and we have the example of electric eels producing intense electric fields. Technologically-assisted telepathy would likely be easier to accomplish.
One major problem in Beneath the Planet of the Apes is the doomsday bomb. The "cobalt bomb" meme, so popular in science fiction, is invoked, and the bomb is surprisingly small. The biggest problem is that the bomb has been kept for two millennia without degradation. Aside from the stability of the chemical explosives used in all such bombs, electrical and electronic components will fail from innocent things like diurnal temperature cycling.
The half-life of plutonium-239 is 24,100 years, but the half-life of another bomb component, tritium, is just 12.4-years, so it needs to be constantly replenished. It would not have been possible for a small group of humans to maintain the weapon, even if they knew how. It costs the United States billions of dollars each year for stockpile stewardship.
It's easy to take potshots at science fiction film and television. At the same time, I realize that they're not intended as science lessons, but as entertainment. However, a little less "deus ex machina" would be refreshing.
- I thoroughly enjoyed the Syfy series, Eureka, but the days for quality shows like that seem to have passed; Eureka (2006-2012) on the Internet Movie Database.
- Beneath the Planet of the Apes (1970, Ted Post, Director), on the Internet Movie Database.
- Zardoz (1974, John Boorman, Director), on the Internet Movie Database.
- Planet of the Apes (1968, Franklin J. Schaffner, Director), on the Internet Movie Database.
Permanent Link to this article
Linked Keywords: Fiction; fictional; book; film; willing suspension of disbelief; English people; English; poet; Samuel Taylor Coleridge; The Rime of the Ancient Mariner; science fiction; sailing ship; course; Antarctica; Moon; Gustav Doré; poem; storm; United States; America; American; Wikimedia Commons; genre; hard science fiction; author; science; scientific; accuracy; imagination; novel; B movie; Syfy channel; 1970; Beneath the Planet of the Apes; weekend; Turner Classic Movies; television advertisement; commercial interruption; Zardoz; apocalyptic; dystopian; theatrical; sequel; 1968; Planet of the Apes; 1963; La Planète des Singes; French; Pierre Boulle; narrative; plot; astronaut; emergency landing; crash landing; planet; Earth; intelligence; intelligent; speech; talking; ape; human; muteness; mute; hunting; hunted; future; nuclear war; destiny; fate; Manhattan; New York City; race; telepathy; telepathic; detonation; detonate; doomsday; nuclear weapon; nuclear device; worship; Star Trek; warp drive; faster-than-light travel; Star Trek transporter; Klingon; exoplanet; constellation; Moon; Solar System; extra-solar planet; English language; Canterbury Tales; vocalize; language; spacecraft; speed of light; light speed; radio communication; city; continent; land area; square mile; open-mindedness; open-minded; evolution; evolve; human brain; electricity; electrical; electric eel; electric field; technology; technological; United States; nuclear weapons testing; Ivy-Mike; thermonuclear weapon; hydrogen bomb; energy; TNT equivalent; megaton; cobalt bomb; meme; millennium; millennia; chemical stability; chemical explosive; electrical and electronic components; reliability engineering"; durnal cycle; temperature; half-life; plutonium-239; tritium; maintenance; dollar; stockpile stewardship; potshot; entertainment; deus ex machina; Eureka television series, 2006-2012; Internet Movie Database.
Latest Books by Dev Gualtieri
Thanks to Cory Doctorow of BoingBoing for his favorable review of Secret Codes!
Blog Article Directory on a Single Page
- Soybean Graphene - March 23, 2017
- Income Inequality and Geometrical Frustration - March 20, 2017
- Wireless Power - March 16, 2017
- Trilobite Sex - March 13, 2017
- Freezing, Outside-In - March 9, 2017
- Ammonia Synthesis - March 6, 2017
- High Altitude Radiation - March 2, 2017
- C.N. Yang - February 27, 2017
- VOC Detection with Nanocrystals - February 23, 2017
- Molecular Fountains - February 20, 2017
- Jet Lag - February 16, 2017
- Highly Flexible Conductors - February 13, 2017
- Graphene Friction - February 9, 2017
- Dynamic Range - February 6, 2017
- Robert Boyle's To-Do List for Science - February 2, 2017
- Nanowire Ink - January 30, 2017
- Random Triangles - January 26, 2017
- Torricelli's law - January 23, 2017
- Magnetic Memory - January 19, 2017
- Graphene Putty - January 16, 2017
- Seahorse Genome - January 12, 2017
- Infinite c - January 9, 2017
- 150 Years of Transatlantic Telegraphy - January 5, 2017
- Cold Work on the Nanoscale - January 2, 2017
- Holidays 2016 - December 22, 2016
- Ballistics - December 19, 2016
- Salted Frogs - December 15, 2016
- Negative Thermal Expansion - December 12, 2016
- Verbal Cues and Stereotypes - December 8, 2016
- Capacitance Sensing - December 5, 2016
- Gallium Nitride Tribology - December 1, 2016
- Lunar Origin - November 27, 2016
- Pumpkin Propagation - November 24, 2016
- Math Anxiety - November 21, 2016
- Borophene - November 17, 2016
- Forced Innovation - November 14, 2016
- Combating Glare - November 10, 2016
- Solar Tilt and Planet Nine - November 7, 2016
- The Proton Size Problem - November 3, 2016
- Coffee Acoustics and Espresso Foam - October 31, 2016
- SnIP - An Inorganic Double Helix - October 27, 2016
- Seymour Papert (1928-2016) - October 24, 2016
- Mapping the Milky Way - October 20, 2016
- Electromagnetic Shielding - October 17, 2016
- The Lunacy of the Cows - October 13, 2016
- Random Coprimes and Pi - October 10, 2016
- James Cronin (1931-2016) - October 6, 2016
- The Ubiquitous Helix - October 3, 2016
- The Five-Second Rule - September 29, 2016
- Resistor Networks - September 26, 2016
- Brown Dwarfs - September 22, 2016
- Intrusion Rheology - September 19, 2016
- Falsifiability - September 15, 2016
- Fifth Force - September 12, 2016
- Renal Crystal Growth - September 8, 2016
- The Normality of Pi - September 5, 2016
- Metering Electrical Power - September 1, 2016
Deep Archive 2006-2008