Tikalon Header Blog Logo

The Lonely Runner Conjecture

August 11, 2011

When I was a college freshman, my dorm mates talked me into being the captain of our intramural track team. It wasn't because I was fleet of foot. In fact, they said I wouldn't need to run at all. I would just act as a records keeper. Perhaps they admired my skill at holding a clipboard.

What they didn't tell me was that when there was an absent runner, the captain needed to run the race. That happened once, I finished dead last, but it did teach me a valuable lesson. When you're volunteering for something, make certain you know what you're volunteering for.

There's an interesting mathematics problem called the lonely runner conjecture. It involves runners who start a race together on a circular track, they all run at different rates, and they're indefatigable; that is, they don't just run till they drop, they run at their constant speed and never drop. The conjecture is that there will be times at which any given runner will be at a distance of at least a fraction (1/n) of the track length from any other runner.

There is one caveat, however. The runners' rates must be pairwise distinct; that is, all rates are different. As typical, the easiest stated conjectures turn out to be hard to prove. Proofs are known up to seven runners, and the seven runner proof was published in 2008.[1-3]

This problem is quite easy to simulate, so I wrote a simulation program, which can be found here. For six runners, the following graph shows the percentage separation from the closest runner for one particular runner over 10,000 steps. The program assigns random running rates to the runners. The fastest runner in this case made a complete circuit in 109 steps, and the slowest runner completed the circuit in 304 steps. A peak separation of 37.9% occurs at 9,000 steps.

lonely runner conjecture

Separation from the closest runner for a particular runner over 10,000 steps in a simulation of the lonely runner conjecture. There's a peak separation of 37.9% at 9,000 steps. (Graph via Gnumeric).


The schematic of the runners' track in the figure below shows the position of the runners at 9,000 steps. There are two "cozy" runners who are separated by just 0.37% of the track length, and the one lonely runner who's 37.9% distant from the nearest runner.

Six runners on a circular track.

Two cozy, and one lonely runner, as calculated by the simulation program.

The runners are at 7.90%, 8.27%, 17.65%, 22.13%, 60.49% and 98.43% of the track length.

(Graph via Gnumeric))


For six runners, the lonely runner conjecture requires merely 1/6 of the track length as the distance to the nearest runner, and we see much more. Why the discrepancy? The (1/n) term is in the conjecture because it makes the problem more tractable. In that form, it can be addressed by Diophantine approximation, which is the approximation of real numbers by rational numbers.

Whenever I see Diophantine equations, the word, piebald, comes to mind. After hearing a word like piebald, how could you forget the context in which you first heard it? In my case it was in the cattle problem, a Diophantine problem supposedly communicated by Archimedes to his friend, Eratosthenes.[4-5] You can view the original Greek text here.[6]

The problem concerns the number of cattle owned by the sun god, Helios, some of which were white, some blue, some yellow, and some piebald. It was basically a Diophantine equation system of seven equations in eight unknowns. Cajori, whom I read as a student, uses the word, piebald.[4-5] Modern authors tend to use terms like dappled and spotted, but I'm a piebald man, through and through.

A paper posted recently on the arXiv preprint server uses Fourier analysis of the lonely runner conjecture to conclude that the separation gets very close to half the track length.[7] This makes a lot of sense, since we can imagine that by waiting long enough, all runners except one will group together, and the remaining runner will be at a random place on the rest of the track. If we're really patient, the random place of the remaining runner will be halfway around the track from the crowd of other runners. This is not a proof, but it gives us a warm feeling.

I leave you with the image of the hand of the anonymous "Googler" who brought us the online text of Cajori's 1894 "A History of Mathematics."[5]

Figure caption

Image found in the online scan of Florian Cajori, "A History of Mathematics," MacMillan Company, (New York, 1894)


References:

  1. Lonely runner conjecture, Open Problem Garden Web Site.
  2. J. Barajas and O. Serra, "The lonely runner with seven runners," arXiv Preprint Server, October 24, 2007.
  3. J. Barajas and O. Serra, "The lonely runner problem with seven runners," The Electronic Journal of Combinatorics, vol. 15, no. R48, pp. 111-116.
  4. Florian Cajori, "A History of Mathematics," MacMillan Company, (New York. 1919), Second Edition, p. 59f. (via Scribd),
  5. Florian Cajori, A History of Mathematics, MacMillan Company, (New York, 1894) , p. 73f. (via Google Books).
  6. Archimedes Cattle Problem, Greek text, New York University.
  7. Sebastian Czerwinski, "Random runners are very lonely," arXiv Preprint Server, February 22, 2011.
  8. C. Harold Horvat and Matthew Stoffregen, "A Solution to the Lonely Runner Conjecture for Almost All Points," arXiv Preprint Server, March 8, 2011.

Permanent Link to this article

Linked Keywords: College freshman; dorm; intramural; track team; clipboard; mathematics; lonely runner conjecture; conjecture; mathematical proof; computer simulation; Diophantine approximation; Diophantine equations; piebald; Archimedes cattle problem; Archimedes; Eratosthenes; Greek language; cattle; Helios; equation; Florian Cajori; arXiv preprint server; Fourier analysis; Googler; A History of Mathematics.

RSS Feed

Google Search


Latest Books by Dev Gualtieri

LGM by Dev Gualtieri
LGM by Dev Gualtieri, paperback LGM by Dev Gualtieri, Kindle

Thanks to Cory Doctorow of BoingBoing for his favorable review of Secret Codes!

Secret Codes & Number Games by Dev Gualtieri
Secret Codes & Number Games by Dev Gualtieri, paperback

Other Books

Other Books by Dev Gualtieri