Blog Logo

Negative Thermal Expansion

November 11, 2011

The vast majority of materials expand when heated, an effect known as thermal expansion. Thermal expansion causes major problems in the manufacture of useful articles. Unless thermal expansion is taken into account during design, camera lenses will defocus, and parts carefully fit at room temperature will fracture as the temperature is increased.

The linear thermal expansion of materials is quantified by the thermal expansion coefficient, which generally goes by the symbol, alpha (α),
α = (1/L)(∂L/∂T)

for which L is the gauge length, T is the temperature, and the dimensions are usually (1/°C). The following table lists the thermal expansion coefficient at room temperature (20°C) for a variety of materials.

Materialα (10-6/°C)Materialα (10-6/°C)
Ethanol250Carbon steel10.8
Stainless steel17.3Borosilicate glass3.3
Concrete12Fused quartz0.59

You can see from the table that hydrogen-bonded liquids (ethanol and water) have a large thermal expansion; and also why mercury was popular in the past for thermometers. It's intuitively easy to see why thermal expansion should exist. Temperature is simply the vibration of atoms, and the vibrational energy will act against the bonding forces that hold atoms together. An end consequence of this is the eventual vaporization of materials into a gas.

That's why negative thermal expansion (NTE) is so unusual. A few isolated examples of NTE were discovered over the years, one of which is water between freezing and 3.984°C.[1] There are so many unusual things about water, that even this brief excursion into NTE didn't raise too many eyebrows. Silicon exhibits NTE in a temperature range of 18 - 120 K.

Hope that some utility can be gained from NTE began in 2004 with the discovery of NTE in an oxide of zirconium and tungsten, cubic zirconium tungstate, ZrW2O8.[2-3] Unlike water, where the temperature range for NTE is very limited, or silicon, where the temperatures are too low to be really useful, zirconium tungstate exhibits NTE from almost absolute zero to 775 °C. Analogs of this material in which hafnium substitutes for zirconium, and molybdenum substitutes for tungsten, also exhibit NTE.

In 2010, scandium fluoride (ScF3), a material with a different crystal structure, was discovered to have an NTE as large as -14 ppm/°C at temperatures from 60-110 K.[4] Its NTE increases to become equivalent to that of zirconium tungstate at room temperature, and the thermal expansion finally becomes positive above 1100 K.[4]

The crystal structure of scandium fluorideThe crystal structure of scandium fluoride.

Drawing by author, rendered with Inkscape.

A research team from the Department of Applied Physics and Materials Science of the California Institute of Technology (Pasadena, California), and the Neutron Scattering Science Division of Oak Ridge National Laboratory (Oak Ridge, Tennessee), has just performed a study to elucidate the mechanism of scandium fluoride's NTE.[5-8] The study was somewhat enabled by the simple lattice structure of the scandium fluoride crystal, as shown in the above figure. The neutron scattering at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory Spallation Neutron Source allowed measurement of the atomic vibrations.[7]

The neutron scattering revealed that all of the atomic resonances remained roughly constant as the temperature was changed, except for one that shifted to higher frequency, an indication of increased bonding force.[6] What apparently happens is that the fluorine atoms are vibrating in a direction transverse to the linear chains of scandium-fluorine-scandium atoms. This is apparently the root cause of the negative thermal expansion.[7]

Principle of negative thermal expansion in scandium fluoride

Principle of negative thermal expansion in scandium fluoride. The fluorine atoms vibrate in a transverse direction to the scandium atoms to pull them together. Drawing by author, rendered with Inkscape.

One curious finding is that the restoring force of the fluorine vibration is a function of the fourth power of the displacement. This quartic oscillation is unlike the quadratic (second power) oscillation that's found in atomic vibrations and harmonic oscillators.[7] Says Brent Fultz, study coauthor and Professor of Materials Science and Applied Physics at Caltech, "A nearly pure quantum quartic oscillator has never been seen in atom vibrations in crystals."[7]

The research team speculates that quartic oscillator materials may also be good thermal insulating materials. NTE materials can be combined with other materials to produce zero expansion materials, at least over a small temperature range. Such materials would be useful in optics, but also things as mundane as dental restoration.[6]


  1. Martin Chaplin, Water Structure and Science - Explanation of the Density Anomalies of Water.
  2. Jason N. Hancock, Chandra Turpen, Zack Schlesinger, Glen R. Kowach and Arthur P. Ramirez, "Unusual Low-Energy Phonon Dynamics in the Negative Thermal Expansion Compound ZrW2O8," Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 93, no. 22 (November 22, 2004), Document No. 225501
  3. David Lindley, "Bake, Shake, and Shrink," Physical Review Focus, vol. 14, no. 21 (November 22, 2004).
  4. Benjamin K. Greve, Kenneth L. Martin, Peter L. Lee, Peter J. Chupas, Karena W. Chapman and Angus P. Wilkinson, "Pronounced Negative Thermal Expansion from a Simple Structure: Cubic ScF3," J. Am. Chem. Soc., vol. 132, no. 44 (November 10, 2010), pp 15496-15498
  5. Chen W. Li, Xiaoli Tang, J. A. Muñoz, J. B. Keith, S. J. Tracy, D. L. Abernathy, and B. Fultz, "Structural Relationship between Negative Thermal Expansion and Quartic Anharmonicity of Cubic ScF3," Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 107, no. 19 (November 4, 2011), Document No. 195504.
  6. Michael Schirber, "New Vibration in Material That Shrinks When Heated," Physics (APS), vol. 4, no. 90 (November 4, 2011).
  7. Marcus Woo, "An Incredible Shrinking Material," California Institute of Technology Press Release, November 4, 2011.
  8. Cal Tech, "An Incredible Shrinking Material," YouTube Video, November 4, 2011.

Permanent Link to this article

Linked Keywords: Material; thermal expansion; design; camera; lens; defocus; fracture; thermal expansion coefficient; temperature; room temperature; ethanol; carbon steel; water; glass; mercury; aluminium; tungsten; stainless steel; borosilicate glass; alumina; copper; Invar; nickel; diamond; concrete; fused quartz; hydrogen-bonded; liquid; thermometer; intuition; vibration; bonding force; atom; vaporization; gas; negative thermal expansion; properties of water; freezing; silicon; Kelvin; K; oxide; zirconium; tungsten; cubic zirconium tungstate; absolute zero; hafnium; molybdenum; scandium fluoride; crystal structure; Inkscape; Department of Applied Physics and Materials Science; California Institute of Technology (Pasadena, California); Neutron Scattering Science Division; Oak Ridge National Laboratory (Oak Ridge, Tennessee); Spallation Neutron Source; frequency; restoring force; displacement; harmonic oscillator; Brent Fultz; thermal insulating; dental restoration.

RSS Feed

Google Search

Latest Books by Dev Gualtieri

LGM by Dev Gualtieri
LGM by Dev Gualtieri, paperback LGM by Dev Gualtieri, Kindle

Thanks to Cory Doctorow of BoingBoing for his favorable review of Secret Codes!

Secret Codes & Number Games by Dev Gualtieri
Secret Codes & Number Games by Dev Gualtieri, paperback

Other Books

Other Books by Dev Gualtieri

Copyright © 2017 Tikalon LLC, All Rights Reserved.
Last Update: 06-22-2017