### Four Square Theorem

September 7, 2011 It seems that every educated person has heard of Fermat's Last Theorem, although it's likely that only the mathematically-minded can state what it is. As I wrote in a previous article (You Can Get There From Here, March 26, 2008), Fermat's Last Theorem simply states that for integers n>2, the equation,ahas no solutions other than a=b=c=0. Princeton University mathematicians Andrew Wiles and Richard Taylor proved the theorem was true in 1994, more than 350 years after it was stated. The conjecture was stated by Pierre de Fermat in 1637, famously in the margin of a copy of Arithmetica by Diophantus. Fermat claimed he had a proof that was too large to fit in the margin. There's a distant cousin to this theorem that's found also in Arithmetica. It's not quite as difficult. Lagrange proved it in 1770, and an undergraduate mathematics major can understand the short proof, which can be found here. It's called Lagrange's Four-Square Theorem, and it's simply the fact that every positive integer^{n}+ b^{n}= c^{n}

**n**can be written as the sum of four squares; that is,

n = awhere^{2}+ b^{2}+ c^{2}+ d^{2},

**a**,

**b**,

**c**and

**d**are integers. Sometimes the qualification, "at most, four squares," is used. If we allow the square of zero, that qualification isn't needed.

__Joseph Louis Lagrange__

Lagrange is known for much more than his mathematics. He's well known to physicists for the Lagrangian; and to astronomers for the Lagrangian points, to name just two.

(Via Wikimedia Commons))

Surprisingly, Euler was not able to prove the theorem himself, although he contributed a piece called the four-square identity. As usual, the theorem started as a conjecture. The conjecture, called Bachet's conjecture, was stated by Claude Gaspard Bachet de Méziriac, a French mathematician and classics scholar, who translated Diophantus' Arithmetica, with commentary, from Greek to Latin in 1621. A portion of the section of the book that describes the conjecture appears below.

*Diophantus Arithmetica, Latin translation by Bachet, 1621, top of page IIII-241. (Via Google Books).[2].*

The last line in the figure reads,

Interim libet id inductione confirmare, ostendendo propriu esse numerorum omnium ab 1 usque ad 120, ut constant ex sequenti diagrammate.Bachet then presents a table of examples for all numbers from 1 - 120 that includes the following:

In the mean time I want to confirm this by induction, specifically by showing it for all of the numbers from 1 to 120, as is evident from the following table.(My translation)

28 = 1In 1798, Adrien-Marie Legendre advanced the theorem by a partial proof that only three squares are needed to represent a positive integer, if, and only if, the integer is not of the form 2^{2}+ 1^{2}+ 1^{2}+ 5^{2}

28 = 1^{2}+ 3^{2}+ 3^{2}+ 3^{2}

28 = 2^{2}+ 2^{2}+ 2^{2}+ 4^{2}

48 = 4^{2}+ 4^{2}+ 4^{2}

48 = 2^{2}+ 2^{2}+ 2^{2}+ 6^{2}

60 = 1^{2}+ 1^{2}+ 3^{2}+ 7^{2}

60 = 1^{2}+ 3^{2}+ 5^{2}+ 5^{2}

60 = 2^{2}+ 2^{2}+ 4^{2}+ 6^{2}

112 = 2^{2}+ 2^{2}+ 2^{2}+ 10^{2}

112 = 2^{2}+ 6^{2}+ 6^{2}+ 6^{2}

112 = 4^{2}+ 4^{2}+ 4^{2}+ 8^{2}

120 = 2^{2}+ 4^{2}+ 10^{2}

^{2k}(8m + 7), where k and m are positive integers. Gauss plugged a gap in Legendre's proof. One very interesting discovery was made by Jacobi, who found that the number of ways a positive integer n can be represented as a sum of four squares is eight times the sum of the divisors of n, for odd n, and 24 times the sum of the odd divisors, for even n. Note that in order to get Jacobi's count, the numbers being squared can be negative, and you need to count all combinations of numbers; that is,

1 = 1^{2}+ 0^{2}+ 0^{2}+ 0^{2}

1 = 0^{2}+ 1^{2}+ 0^{2}+ 0^{2}

1 = (-1)^{2}+ 0^{2}+ 0^{2}+ 0^{2}

etc...

### References:

- Eric W. Weisstein, "Lagrange's Four-Square Theorem," MathWorld--A Wolfram Web Resource.
- Claude Gaspar Bachet, translator: "Diophantus of Alexandria, Arithmetica," 1621, via Google Books.

*Permanent Link to this article*

Linked Keywords: Liberal arts; Fermat's Last Theorem; mathematics; integer; equation; Princeton University; Andrew Wiles; Richard Taylor; conjecture; Arithmetica; Diophantus; Lagrange; undergraduate; Lagrange's Four-Square Theorem; square; Lagrangian; Lagrangian point; Wikimedia Commons; Euler; four-square identity; Claude Gaspard Bachet de Méziriac; French; mathematician; classics; Greek; Latin; Google Books; Adrien-Marie Legendre; if, and only if; Gauss; Jacobi's four-square theorem; Carl Gustav Jacob Jacobi; Eric W. Weisstein.

### Google Search

Latest Books by Dev Gualtieri

Thanks to Cory Doctorow of BoingBoing for his favorable review of Secret Codes!

Other Books

- John Archibald Wheeler - March 25, 2019

- The Year 536 - March 18, 2019

- 150 Years of the Periodic Table - March 11, 2019

- Sloan Digital Sky Survey MaNGA - March 4, 2019

- Ductile High-Entropy Alloys - February 25, 2019

- Cooling with Aerosols - February 18, 2019

- Magnetic North - February 11, 2019

- Metal-Air Transistor - February 4, 2019

- Crazy Number Sequences - January 28, 2019

- Thermal Filtering - January 21, 2019

- Strong Wood - January 14, 2019

- Ultima Thule - January 7, 2019

- Holidays 2018 - December 23, 2018

- Electron Symmetry - December 17, 2018

- Lottery Simulation - December 10, 2018

- Walter Schottky - December 3, 2018

- Exfoliated Graphite - November 26, 2018

- Solar Reflecting Paint - November 19, 2018

- Metaphysics - November 12, 2018

- Bus Stop Simulation - November 5, 2018

- Printed Piezoelectrics - October 29, 2018

- Women Nobel Laureates in 2018 - October 22, 2018

- Neolithic Cheese - October 15, 2018

- Michael Faraday - October 8, 2018

- NIST Randomness Beacon - October 1, 2018

- Supercooled Water - September 24, 2018

- Euler on Divergent Series - September 17, 2018

- Giant Magnetocaloric Effect - September 10, 2018

- Synthetic Fragrances - September 3, 2018

### Deep Archive

Deep Archive 2006-2008

**Blog Article Directory on a Single Page**